A Review of Home Neck Traction Units

85

By Back2Basics

Neck Traction Units: A review

Several conditions respond well to cervical traction and many traction units are available for home use. Multiple claims are made as to which neck traction device is the best to treat cervical pain but what sets these neck traction units apart? Price, Comfort and function vary greatly among the Cervical traction units available for home use and the buyer should be aware of all the options available.

Cervical traction is beneficial for people suffering from neck pain as a result of osteoarthritis, whiplash injuries, loss of cervical curve and degenerative disc disease. Those with herniated discs, pinched nerves and chronic neck strains may also find relief from pain from a home neck traction unit. Headache sufferers may also benefit from cervical traction use.

As with any other medical product, it is strongly suggested that you consult a health care professional before using a neck traction device at home.

Is your pain related to computer use? Click here

Goals of neck traction

Neck traction has several benefits:

  • Reduce nerve impingement
  • Reduce disc herniation
  • Restore normal cervical curve
  • Reduce joint irritation
  • Elongate cervical muscles
While each neck traction manufacturer will claim their unit is better, each has a different approach and cost that will contribute to the buyers decision.


Overhead Traction Devices

Overhead or over the door traction devices are the basic option available. Often using weights or water, these devices work to distract the cervical spine and take pressure off the joints, nerves and discs.

They are the most cost effective of the cervical traction units but are also the least beneficial. These devices only pull the neck up, they do not help to restore the cervical curve because the line of correction is straight up.

Most Cost Effective

Least Therapeutic


Disadvantage

  • Pressure put on jaw and TMJ
  • Force is not easily adjustable
  • No cervical curve enhancement

Advantages

  • Portable
  • Inexpensive
  • Does not require much space

ComforTrac

Comfortrac is a high end model of cervical traction that uses an advanced form of the overhead model. The Comfortrac features a sliding distraction system which lets the user control the amount of force applied through an air pump. This is advantageous in that as the muscles relax after initial contraction additional force can be applied to increase the length of the traction. It also features adjustable neck wedges and a memory foam pillow. 

The adjustable height provides the user to change the angle of the neck but it does not have any function which stresses the cervical curve. 


Disadvantages

  • Expensive
  • Does not stress cervical curve
  • Bulky

Advantages

  • Variable pressure
  • Adjustable height
  • Supportive cushion

Posture Pump

The posture pump features an adjustable air bladder along with chin and head straps to stress the cervical curve and add support. This results in extension of the spine overall but with an accentuation of the cervical curve. Much like the Comfortrac it uses air to control the pressure only the Posture Pump increases the bladder lying in the curve of the neck rather than stretching the spine overall.

Advantages

  • Affordable
  • Adjustable pressure
  • Stresses cervical curve

Disadvantages

  • Slightly restrictive
  • Fabric on bubble not washable
  • Non adjustable neck height

Summary

The outdated over the door traction unit may help to alleviate neck pain for the short run but long term results may prove to be minimal. The Comfortrac is a sound unit but lacks the attention to restoring the cervical curve and is extremely expensive. The Posture Pump affords the best bang for the buck with its durable construction and emphasis on restoring the curve.

Comments

parrster profile image

parrster Level 3 Commenter 2 years ago

Great hub. thanks

gidtset profile image

gidtset 23 months ago

Great information.:-)

ChristinCordle12 profile image

ChristinCordle12 10 months ago

Great hub. very interesting.

AmberDW 9 months ago

What about the wedge or chair-type units? Like the Cervical Curve Correction Device? Would that be more beneficial than the posture pump or less?

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    • Is Chiropractic Legitimate?

      Chiropractic continues to be the largest and most accepted of the alternative health providers. Even with the growing number of chiropractic clinics and centers found in most towns and cities, chiropractors continue to suffer... - 16 months ago

    • Chiropractic EMR & Billing Reviewing the best and worst

      I set out trying to find the best Chiropractic EMR for the best value. I wanted to utilize a system which would provide me with practice management software that would also accomodate my billing needs as a Chiropractor. The desired program would... - 23 months ago

    • A Review of Home Neck Traction Units

      Several conditions respond well to cervical traction and many traction units are available for home use. Multiple claims are made as to which neck traction device is the best to treat cervical pain but what sets these neck traction units apart?... - 2 years ago

    • Treatment for neck pain: Kinesio Taping.

      I have found that one of the best treatments for neck pain is through the application of Kinesio Tape. Kinesio tape, when used in conjunction with other treatments, significantly reduces the pain caused by... - 2 years ago

    • Neck Pain and Headaches from computer use.

      Information about neck pain caused by computer use. Examining how computer use causes neck pain will lead to better treatment of neck pain as well as give the reader with neck pain tips for reducing their neck pain - 3 years ago

    Please wait working